Short answer
Listen, then check before you change anything. Your Google rep works for Google, and most of what they push (broad match, AI Max, auto-applied recommendations, bigger budgets) earns Google more whether or not it books you more jobs.
Never let anyone accept recommendations in your account during a phone call. Get the suggestion in writing and judge it on cost per real lead, not clicks and not the conversions Google says you missed.
What we’ve seen in real accounts
What one rep call did to a junk removal account
A rep called one of our junk removal clients and got the newest employee on the phone. By the end of that call the keywords were on broad match, AI Max for Search was on, and the budgets were higher. All of it came straight off Google's recommendations tab.
Broad match in a junk removal account pulls in city trash, bulk pickup and waste management searches, because Google files junk removal close to waste management. The change history showed a full day of changes to undo it. We dropped the budget for the rest of that month so the account wasn't paying for trash-day clicks while it settled, and cost per lead ran higher while it relearned. That's the real price of a five-minute call.
The "you missed conversions" email
Those emails say how many more conversions you could have had. They never say what those extra conversions would have cost, or whether they'd be booked jobs or people asking when the city picks up couches.
What to do
- Lock down who can change the account. The owner and whoever runs the ads get edit access. Everyone else gets read-only, so nobody can be walked through changes on a sales call.
- Turn auto-apply off. In Recommendations, check that auto-apply is off. When it is on, Google applies some recommendation types by itself.
- Ask the cost question. "What does this do to my cost per lead, and how will we know?" If the answer is "more conversions", you didn't get an answer.
- Read the search terms after any match type change. A few days after broad match goes on, open the search terms report. Trash pickup, dump hours and free-dumpster searches mean it is costing you.
- Use change history when results drop. It shows who changed what and when. If leads fell after a call, that's where you find out why. If you want a second set of eyes, that's what our Google Ads management work does.
What this doesn’t prove
This is one account's story, not a study of rep calls, so there are no numbers from it on this page. Plenty of reps are decent people. The point is who signs their paycheck.
Questions operators ask
- Does my Google Ads rep work for me?
- No. Google reps are Google employees. They can be helpful on setup questions, but their job is to grow spend on Google, so check every suggestion against your own cost per lead.
- Should I accept Google Ads recommendations?
- Read them, accept few. In our accounts most get dismissed: broad match, AI Max and budget raises in particular. Keep auto-apply off so nothing changes without someone deciding it.
- Why did my Google Ads get worse after a call with Google?
- Check change history for that day. The usual culprits are a switch to broad match, AI Max turned on, or a budget jump, any of which can flood a junk removal account with trash pickup searches.
Sources
- Our PPC team's walkthrough of the account above: its change history and search terms, reviewed in the account. No figures from it are published.
- Match types in our own accounts: Broad, phrase or exact match for junk removal.
For more like this, join the newsletter.