Is the top Google ad spot worth paying for in home services?
In 20 home service Google Search ad accounts (May–Oct 2026), top-of-page clicks converted better in 17 of 20 and cost more in 20 of 20, but top-of-page leads were cheaper in only 7 of 18.
- Medians, same accounts: conversion rate 12.36% at the top vs 8.27% lower down; cost per click $7.53 vs $4.53; cost per lead $62.90 vs $62.28.
- Inside each account, the top-of-page lead cost a median 109.45 of the lower one (100 = the same).
- The top was most of the account anyway: a median 84.88% of clicks and 91.29% of leads.
- Position is where the ad showed, not a setting you pick. It moves with your bid, budget, ad quality and the search.
By Justin Hubbard, who runs Adimize and has owned and operated a junk removal and dumpster rental company for over 12 years
Based on 30 home service Google Ads accounts (23 junk removal and 7 dumpster rental), Search campaigns, May 1 - Oct 31, 2026; top vs lower compared within 20 of them
Top of page vs lower on the page, same accounts
| Same account, May–Oct 2026 | Top of page (median) | Lower on the page (median) | Top as % of lower, same account (median, 100 = same) | Account-by-account result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion rate | 12.36% | 8.27% | 134.77 | Top converted better in 17 of 20 |
| Cost per click | $7.53 | $4.53 | 161.13 | Top clicks cost more in 20 of 20 |
| Cost per lead | $62.90 | $62.28 | 109.45 | Top leads cost less in 7 of 18 |
| Click-through rate | 12.81% | 1.57% | n/a | Top higher in 20 of 20 |
How much of the account was top of page
| Where the ad showed | Share of clicks (median, 30 accounts) | Share of spend (median) | Share of leads (median) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top of page (above the organic results) | 84.88% | 90.12% | 91.29% |
| Lower on the page | 8.07% | 7.65% | 7.27% |
Junk removal accounts only
| Junk removal accounts only, May–Oct 2026 | Result |
|---|---|
| Top converted better | 14 of 15 |
| Top clicks cost more | 15 of 15 |
| Top leads cost less | 5 of 14 |
| Top cost per lead as % of lower (median, 100 = same) | 109.45 |
What the numbers say
Every owner wants to be the first ad. I get it. You search your own service, you see a competitor above you, and it eats at you. So I pulled Google's "Top vs. Other" report across 30 home service accounts for May through October 2026 and compared the two spots inside each account. Top means above the unpaid results. Lower means Google's "Other": below or beside them.
The top spot does get better clicks. In 20 accounts with enough clicks in both places, top-of-page clicks converted better in 17 (median 12.36% vs 8.27%). The click-through rate (the share of people who saw the ad and clicked it) was higher at the top in all 20.
You pay for it, though. Top clicks cost more in all 20 accounts: a median $7.53 vs $4.53. Put the two together and the lead itself was cheaper at the top in only 7 of 18 accounts. Inside each account, the top-of-page lead cost a median 109.45 of the lower one, where 100 is the same. So in our data the top spot mostly bought better clicks at a price that made the lead cost about the same or more.
Junk removal on its own looked the same. In 15 junk removal accounts, the top converted better in 14, but the lead was cheaper at the top in only 5 of 14.
None of this means "get off the top." The top was most of the account: a median 84.88% of clicks and 91.29% of leads. Lower on the page was 8.07% of clicks and 7.27% of leads. The point is that paying extra to force your way to the top isn't automatically worth it.
Read it with the limits in mind. Position isn't a setting you pick; Google moves your ad around with your bid, budget, ad quality and the search. Top and lower clicks also come from different searches at different times, so this isn't a test. It's what shows up together in our data. And we can't see job size or profit from ad data, only leads as each account tracks them.
What I'd do with this (my take, not the data):
- Judge the account on cost per lead and cost per booked job, not on where your ad sits. If you want to see where you show, use the Ad Preview tool in Google Ads instead of searching yourself.
- Don't use a bid strategy that targets top-of-page or absolute-top share just to be first. In our data that spot cost more per click in all 20 accounts we could compare.
- Check it in your own account: Campaigns, then Segment, then Top vs. Other. Compare conversion rate and cost per conversion for each over at least 90 days.
- If you want more of the top spot, earn it with better ads and a better landing page first. That's how Google decides who shows where, along with the bid.
How often your ads show and why they miss: losing to budget or ad rank? Which bid strategy to run: Google Ads bid strategy. What a click costs in the first place: cost per click. And which part of the ad gets the leads: call button vs headline vs sitelinks.
The bigger plan is on junk removal marketing and dumpster rental marketing. Bidding for leads instead of position is part of our paid ads work. For more numbers like these, get the newsletter.
How we got this
- Source: Google Ads (Search campaigns, "Top vs. Other" position segment), accounts we manage or audit, via Windsor.ai read-only API.
- Window: May 1 to Oct 31, 2026. Pulled 2026-11-21.
- Sample: 30 home service accounts (23 junk removal and 7 dumpster rental) with 10+ Search leads and 100+ Search clicks in the window; 88,669 Search clicks and 9,847.7 leads added together (Google can split credit for a lead, so the total isn't a whole number). Top vs lower is compared within an account only where it had 30+ clicks in both positions (20 accounts), and for cost per lead 3+ leads in both (18).
- Top: Google's "Top" position: Search ads shown above the organic (unpaid) results.
- Lower: Google's "Other" position on Google Search: ads shown lower on the results page, below or beside the organic results.
- Leads: A Google Ads conversion in a Search campaign (calls from ads, calls from the website, forms, as each account tracks them).
- Exclusions: Excluded: one removed client, one empty account, and accounts with too little activity in the window (thresholds in method). Accounts are counted once each; no account, business, domain or town is named. Local Services, Performance Max, Display and Smart campaigns are left out. Search Partner and Display-expansion clicks are shown as shares only. Dumpster rental is not reported on its own (5 accounts compared, 4 for cost per lead).
- Caveats: Position is where the ad showed, not a setting the advertiser picks directly; it moves with bids, budget, ad quality and the search. Correlation, not cause: top-of-page and lower clicks come from different searches and times, not a controlled test. We cannot see job size or profit, only leads as each account tracks them.
FAQ
Is it worth paying for the top spot on Google Ads?
Not automatically. In 20 home service Google Search ad accounts (May–Oct 2026), top-of-page clicks converted better in 17 and cost more in 20, but top-of-page leads were cheaper in only 7 of 18. Judge it on cost per lead, not position.
Do top-of-page Google Ads convert better?
Usually, in our data. Median conversion rate was 12.36% at the top vs 8.27% lower on the page, and the top did better in 17 of 20 home service accounts (May–Oct 2026).
How much more does a top-of-page click cost?
A median $7.53 at the top vs $4.53 lower on the page, across 20 home service accounts (May–Oct 2026). Top clicks cost more in all 20.
What is "Other" in Google Ads Top vs. Other?
Ads that showed on Google Search below or beside the unpaid results instead of above them. You can see it under Campaigns, then Segment, then Top vs. Other.
Can I choose to show at the top of the page?
Not directly. Google decides where your ad shows in each search from your bid, your ad and landing page quality, and the search itself. Bid strategies that target top-of-page share push bids up to get there.