Does Ad Strength matter for home service Google Ads?
Across home service Google Ads accounts (Aug–Oct 2026), ads rated Good or Excellent converted better than Average or Poor ads in only 8 of 21 accounts compared, and brought cheaper leads in only 5 of 17.
- Median cost per lead: $100.93 on Good/Excellent ads vs $80.75 on Average/Poor (17 accounts).
- Poor ads did look weak: a 2.96% conversion rate, all accounts added together, against 8.9% for Average.
- Most money already sits on the green ratings: a median 88.36% of rated ad spend went to Good or Excellent ads (33 accounts).
- Google says Ad Strength isn't used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or auction wins.
By Justin Hubbard, who runs Adimize and has owned and operated a junk removal and dumpster rental company for over 12 years
Based on 33 home service Google Ads accounts (25 junk removal, 6 dumpster rental, 1 other and 1 unclassified), responsive search ads in Search campaigns, Aug 1 - Oct 31, 2026; Ad Strength as shown on Nov 19, 2026
Good/Excellent vs Average/Poor ads, same accounts
| Same accounts, Aug–Oct 2026 | Good or Excellent ads (median) | Average or Poor ads (median) | Accounts where Good/Excellent did better |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion rate | 7.21% | 6.62% | 8 of 21 (converted better) |
| Cost per click | $7.28 | $6.63 | 9 of 21 (click cheaper) |
| Click-through rate | 6.67% | 6.83% | 7 of 21 (more clicks per view) |
| Cost per lead (17 accounts) | $100.93 | $80.75 | 5 of 17 (lead cheaper) |
Where the ad money goes by rating
| Measure (Aug–Oct 2026) | Median account | Middle half | Accounts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share of rated ad spend on Good or Excellent ads | 88.36% | 55.35%–99.51% | 33 |
| Share of rated ad spend on Excellent ads | 45.81% | 10.38%–80% | 33 |
| Share of rated ad spend on Good ads | 14.76% | 0.02%–44.18% | 33 |
| Share of rated ad spend on Average ads | 6.58% | 0.09%–44.65% | 33 |
| Share of rated ad spend on Poor ads | 0% | 0%–1.94% | 33 |
| Accounts that got leads from Average or Poor ads | 21 of 33 | n/a | 33 |
| Accounts that got leads from Poor ads | 9 of 33 | n/a | 33 |
Results by rating, all accounts added together
| Ad Strength | Conversion rate | Share of spend | Share of clicks | Accounts with this rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Excellent | 7.18% | 43.52% | 56.72% | 28 |
| Good | 13.5% | 28.63% | 19.6% | 27 |
| Average | 8.9% | 25.46% | 20.43% | 25 |
| Poor | 2.96% | 2.39% | 3.25% | 16 |
What the numbers say
Ad Strength is the Poor-to-Excellent meter Google shows while you write a responsive search ad. Google calls it "a tool that helps you create effective responsive search ads" and says it "isn't used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score, or auction wins" (Google's Ad Strength help page). So it's a writing checklist. The question is whether a greener meter comes with more calls. In our data, mostly not.
We compared Good or Excellent ads with Average or Poor ads inside the same account, 21 accounts with enough clicks on both sides. Good/Excellent converted better in 8 of 21. The click was cheaper in 9 of 21. More people clicked after seeing the ad in 7 of 21. And the lead was cheaper in only 5 of 17 accounts (median $100.93 vs $80.75).
Poor is the exception. With all accounts added together, Poor ads converted at 2.96%, against 8.9% for Average, 13.5% for Good and 7.18% for Excellent. Poor ads only ran in 16 accounts and took 2.39% of the spend, so it's a small pile. Still, 9 of 33 accounts got at least one lead from a Poor ad.
Read it with the limits in mind. The rating is read once, on the day we pulled it, and an ad edited during the window may have rated differently then. Ads in the same account sit in different ad groups with different keywords, so this isn't a clean test. It's what goes together in our data, not proof of what the rating does.
Don't mix it up with Quality Score. Quality Score is Google's 1 to 10 grade on each keyword, built from expected click-through rate, ad relevance and the landing page. Ad Strength only looks at the ad text. How Quality Score lined up with lead cost: Quality Score in home service accounts.
What I'd do with this (my take, not the data):
- Fix Poor ads. Usually that means adding more headlines and making them different from each other instead of five ways of saying "junk removal".
- Don't rewrite an ad that's booking jobs just to turn the meter green. A rewritten ad starts its numbers over, and you lose the track record you were judging it on.
- Judge ads on calls, texts, quote requests and cost per lead. Open Ads, add the Conversions and Cost / conv. columns, and sort by those.
Normal click-through and conversion rates for comparison: click-through and conversion rate. Getting more of those clicks to turn into calls: improve Google Ads conversions. Who is actually clicking: age and gender of Google Ads leads.
The bigger plan is on junk removal marketing and dumpster rental marketing. Ad copy is one of the things we check in a Google Ads audit, and writing ads that book jobs is our paid ads work. For more numbers like these, get the newsletter.
How we got this
- Source: Google Ads via Windsor.ai (read-only), Search campaigns, responsive search ads, grouped by Ad Strength.
- Window: Aug 1 to Oct 31, 2026 for results; Ad Strength as shown on 2026-11-19.
- Sample: 33 home service accounts (25 junk removal, 6 dumpster rental, 1 other and 1 unclassified); 21 had enough clicks on both sides to compare, 17 enough leads to compare cost per lead. Thresholds: 100+ clicks on rated ads per account; 30+ clicks on each side of a comparison; 3+ leads on each side for cost per lead; 5+ accounts behind any number.
- Method: Ads grouped by the Ad Strength Google shows for them: "Good or Excellent" vs "Average or Poor". Inside each account that had 30+ clicks on both sides, we compared conversion rate, cost per click, click-through rate and cost per lead, then counted how many accounts went each way and took the median account. Unrated and "pending" ads are left out.
- Exclusions: Excluded: one removed client, one empty account, and accounts with too little activity in the window (thresholds in method). Accounts are counted once each; no account, business, domain or town is named. Performance Max, Local Services and Display campaigns are not included (Ad Strength here is for responsive search ads).
- Caveats: Ad Strength is read once (at pull time). An ad edited during the window may have had a different rating then. Ads in the same account can sit in different ad groups with different keywords, so the two sides aren't a controlled test. Leads are conversions as each account tracks them. In our data, not cause.
- What Google says Ad Strength is: Google Ads Help, "About Ad Strength for responsive search ads" (https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/9921843), read 2026-11-19.
FAQ
Does Ad Strength matter in Google Ads?
Less than the meter suggests. Across home service accounts (Aug–Oct 2026), Good or Excellent ads converted better than Average or Poor ads in only 8 of 21 accounts and brought cheaper leads in only 5 of 17. Google says it isn't used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or auction wins.
Should I rewrite my ads to get Excellent Ad Strength?
Not if they're booking jobs. In our data a higher rating didn't line up with cheaper leads in most accounts (5 of 17). Fix Poor ads, then judge every ad on calls and cost per lead.
Are Poor Ad Strength ads worth fixing?
Yes. With all accounts added together, Poor ads converted at 2.96%, against 8.9% for Average (Aug–Oct 2026). They were a small share of spend (2.39%), but they were the weakest group.
Is Ad Strength the same as Quality Score?
No. Quality Score is a 1 to 10 grade Google gives each keyword. Ad Strength rates the text of a responsive search ad from Poor to Excellent, and Google says it isn't used to calculate Quality Score.